| 
  FlyingTypers 
                                                    sat down with Volker Zintel, 
                                                    project manager for air transport 
                                                    and security for the House 
                                                    of Logistics & Mobility 
                                                    (HOLM). Mr. Zintel has a wealth 
                                                    of experience and is well 
                                                    connected; he served as executive 
                                                    VP for FRAPORT in charge of 
                                                    security, was the erstwhile 
                                                    police chief at the airport 
                                                    during the 1981-1984 Startbahn 
                                                    West (takeoff runway) construction 
                                                    years, which were plagued 
                                                    by violent demonstrations 
                                                    by its opponents, and was 
                                                    interwoven with politics as 
                                                    Mayor of Hochheim, an idyllic 
                                                    town known for its wines that 
                                                    lies 20 minutes southwest 
                                                    of Frankfurt. HOLM 
                                                    is a fully financed initiative 
                                                    of the Hessian state and the 
                                                    Frankfurt city government 
                                                    with the objective of bringing 
                                                    together an effective network 
                                                    of science, politics, and 
                                                    the economy to systematically 
                                                    further develop the logistics 
                                                    of the region. It also aims 
                                                    to project concentric circles 
                                                    to attract global expertise 
                                                    and develop a new approach 
                                                    to the socio-economic challenges 
                                                    affecting the sustainability 
                                                    of Germany as a logistics 
                                                    powerhouse. It’s not 
                                                    something one gets done in 
                                                    an afternoon, but rather a 
                                                    long-term vision borne from 
                                                    the recognition that the key 
                                                    players—airlines, airports, 
                                                    and air traffic control—have 
                                                    not succeeded, individually 
                                                    or collectively, in communicating 
                                                    with the public effectively, 
                                                    and that endangers the long-term 
                                                    viability of Europe’s 
                                                    third largest passenger and 
                                                    number one cargo airport. 
                                                    And it’s not just the 
                                                    airport per se, but the economic 
                                                    engine that has brought a 
                                                    level of prosperity that many 
                                                    have long taken for granted.
 Frankfurt airport is intermodal 
                                                    when it comes to passengers 
                                                    – the vast underground 
                                                    train station handles anything 
                                                    from regional to metro area 
                                                    traffic with great efficiency. 
                                                    As urban trends go, families 
                                                    with small children are attracted 
                                                    to the greener suburbs and 
                                                    smaller towns only to discover 
                                                    that commuting to a workplace 
                                                    in the city becomes quite 
                                                    a chore. The convenient public 
                                                    transportation network doesn’t 
                                                    extend beyond the city limits, 
                                                    so eventually, the families 
                                                    return. Current studies have 
                                                    established that another 10 
                                                    percent growth in metro public 
                                                    transportation demand would 
                                                    collapse the entire system, 
                                                    bringing it to its knees. 
                                                    Adding tracks and railcars 
                                                    has limits.
 Then 
                                                    there is the paradox of the 
                                                    well-heeled Burger flying 
                                                    off to Phuket or the Maldives 
                                                    for some sun and relaxation, 
                                                    and once back home sits down 
                                                    comfortably to e-mail complaints 
                                                    about airport noise, without 
                                                    seemingly connecting the dots. 
                                                    It is also a sign of the times—the 
                                                    conundrum of the quality of 
                                                    life of an individual versus 
                                                    the benefit to society as 
                                                    a whole.
 A 
                                                    few generations ago there 
                                                    were demonstrations against 
                                                    the Vietnam War, then against 
                                                    nuclear power plants and the 
                                                    storage of spent fuel rods, 
                                                    which mobilized activism. 
                                                    Environmental movements of 
                                                    all sorts have since sprouted 
                                                    up and are now seeing another 
                                                    incarnation in protests against 
                                                    the airport, and special focus 
                                                    on the new northwest runway, 
                                                    opened last October, and the 
                                                    noise resulting from new flight 
                                                    approach patterns. Given the 
                                                    flight frequencies, at certain 
                                                    times of the day apparently 
                                                    the noise is nearly constant, 
                                                    affecting a whole new group 
                                                    of citizens whose lives have 
                                                    been disrupted. From day one 
                                                    of opening the new runway, 
                                                    landing traffic has been divided 
                                                    50-50 between the old and 
                                                    the new runway, so that the 
                                                    impact was massive and immediate. 
                                                    Forethought by all concerned 
                                                    could have come up with a 
                                                    better solution to gradually 
                                                    shift the flights in 10 percent 
                                                    increments at a time.
 The 
                                                    backlash has taken politicians 
                                                    completely by surprise, according 
                                                    to Herr Zintel, and the authorities 
                                                    as a whole have been ill prepared 
                                                    to address it—resulting 
                                                    in a communications disaster. 
                                                    The facts, if that mattered, 
                                                    are that compared to 1980 
                                                    and 1990, the overall airport 
                                                    noise level is unchanged; 
                                                    the former US Airbase and 
                                                    the lumbering C-5, C-17, and 
                                                    C-130 are gone. Modern aircraft 
                                                    have a significantly smaller 
                                                    noise footprint, yet the overall 
                                                    number of flights has grown.
 And 
                                                    it’s not just Frankfurt 
                                                    that received the entire media 
                                                    blitz—a recent referendum 
                                                    in Munich decided against 
                                                    building a much-needed third 
                                                    runway by 54 to 46, initiated 
                                                    by the Green party. And the 
                                                    citizenry of Munich is virtually 
                                                    unaffected by airport noise 
                                                    because of its location 25 
                                                    miles northeast of the city, 
                                                    while the communes nearby 
                                                    had no vote, yet are next 
                                                    door. And again, the politicians 
                                                    were embarrassed because right, 
                                                    left, and center lobbied for 
                                                    building the 3rd runway. Societal 
                                                    changes have generated a citizenry 
                                                    ready to defend its lifestyle 
                                                    and any real or perceived 
                                                    infringement on it triggers 
                                                    an outcry. Under these circumstances, 
                                                    it becomes very difficult 
                                                    to sustain, plan, and further 
                                                    develop modern transportation 
                                                    hubs, which, when measured, 
                                                    are actually bursting at the 
                                                    seams.
 HOLM 
                                                    aims to tackle this thorny 
                                                    and complex phenomenon by 
                                                    bringing together an aviation 
                                                    management cluster comprised 
                                                    of multidisciplinary experts. 
                                                    Twelve universities, faculties 
                                                    and institutes in the state 
                                                    of Hesse (Hessen) are involved 
                                                    to varying degrees—economists, 
                                                    social scientists, and an 
                                                    advisory board including businesses 
                                                    such as Bombardier, Deutsche 
                                                    Post DHL, Proctor & Gamble, 
                                                    and FRAPORT. Contacts to the 
                                                    Freie Universität Berlin 
                                                    are ongoing, all in a concerted 
                                                    effort to promote openness 
                                                    and transparency and address 
                                                    global challenges.
 On 
                                                    the cargo side, FRAPORT works 
                                                    with HOLM on a joint taskforce 
                                                    to study the chronic Cargo 
                                                    City congestion problems. 
                                                    With up to 1,200 trucks a 
                                                    day during peak time but only 
                                                    600 parking spots, it has 
                                                    become an unmanageable situation. 
                                                    There are many warehouses 
                                                    to handle cargo, but Cargo 
                                                    City was built without a rigorous 
                                                    study of the needs. It turns 
                                                    out even recently there has 
                                                    been insufficient data available 
                                                    regarding the breakdown of 
                                                    truck movements, directional 
                                                    information, or how many drops 
                                                    each makes. There was the 
                                                    anecdotal case of a truck 
                                                    that made 17 drops. Contrary 
                                                    to other major cargo projects, 
                                                    such as the port of Hamburg, 
                                                    which was well planned and 
                                                    designed, at Cargo City this 
                                                    is being done after the fact.
 There 
                                                    is much to do and only a much 
                                                    more collaborative approach 
                                                    and openness to new concepts 
                                                    and ideas can succeed. It’s 
                                                    a recurring theme—airlines, 
                                                    handling companies, and airports 
                                                    all need to turn a profit, 
                                                    and clearly each has divergent 
                                                    objectives, but it cannot 
                                                    be at each other’s expense.
Ted 
                                                    Braun |